Whether you had an awesome experience or have some constructive criticism for us, we’re all ears! We pride ourselves on using your feedback to make our restaurant better. You’d be surprised by how many of our team members actually read your comments, from company founder Brewer Stouffer to the server who just brought your pizza to the table. If you take a few moments to reach out, your comment will be the topic of our next staff improvement meeting (can you imagine what happens at those?).





Would you like to be a part of the Candle Club?
 Yep, please add my name and birthday to the club!

Whitefish Bay, WI

Friendly and prompt service. Very inviting and soothing decor. Love the huge variety of different pizzas and toppings and most importantly, LOVE that ..

- Carol F.

Middleton, WI

The service and pizza were excellent. I love the fact that you can get gluten free crust because my wife is gluten intolerant. We will be back soon.

- Paul H.

Fitchburg, WI

I love the crust of your pizza, the topping options, the selections of beer is excellent, and your specials on wine throughout the week are also great..

- Michelle R.

Fitchburg, WI

Great atmosphere and great pizza. Killer combination.

- Scott J.

Middleton, WI

Kevin B. Pizza was hot and exact to order. Ingredients are superb and especially like the fireworks sauce. I also enjoy your craft beer tap selecti..

- Kevin B.

Willy St., Madison, WI

Our pizza and atmosphere was great but more than anything the service was fantastic. We wish we had a server like this at every restaurant we went to...

- Brittany R.